How to get crappy, but easy and cheap, advice on legal gun use

It is surprisingly easy to get bad – and I mean really bad – advice on the legal aspects of defensive gun use. We all know that gun store clerks are not good, and are often worse than terrible, sources, but there are other, seemingly credible, sources that are just as bad.

  • Lawyers  Most lawyers aren’t criminal law lawyers; of those that are most aren’t use of force specialists; of those few have experience with lethal force; and of those almost none have defended an innocent person (whose defense is considerably different in both strategy and tactics than that of a guilty person).  I have seen lawyers give the same dangerous, completely off-base advice that gun store clerks give, and have the same inappropriate and incorrect reaction to a case in the news that you’d expect of the most malicious, Alinskyite leftie.  Plus lawyers think they know everything.  Look to Andrew Branca, Marty Hayes, and Mas Ayoob for credible legal advice.
  • Cops  Most cops only know what little law they learned in the academy, and that was considerably watered-down from the law school version of the same.  Most cops have no interest in firearms or the legal aspects of use of force and don’t know much about them.  Their advice is often a mix of ignorance and the testosterone that comes with the job.  Now, often a cop that has become a firearms instructor through their state process has a reasonable handle of the subject, but on the other hand all too many cops become FIs just to punch a ticket or get a raise.  Even the most knowledgeable LE FIs are often inarticulate, so even they can’t do you any good.
  • Websites  Websites devoted to national issues, run by other than the three gentleman (really – they are!) named above, can’t be expert on all state issues.  Websites run by people devoted to state legal issues are often pretty ignorant, too.  I have first-hand experience here in my state with a website run by an instructor, which had become an often-referenced source of information on our confusing gun laws, being completely wrong on some issues.
  • State officials  Your state’s AG usually has no interest in explaining the law correctly to you, no incentive to do so, and suffers no penalties for giving you wrong information.  Ditto your DA.  When they even make a feeble attempt at it, it is often so general, conservative, and non-specific that it is all but useless.  I’ve seen a police chief, appointed by my state to be the chief’s association expert on our confusing gun laws, provide wrong advice in writing.

So who do you trust?  The three men listed above, really.  Atty. Branca even has state-specific appendices in his absolutely must-read book, and more information available on his website.  For non-force related laws, such as storage, weapon restrictions, etc., you’ll 1) have to read the actual statutes (free), 2) read the relevant case law (you might have to pay to get them), and 3) find, through arduous research, a source or two you can trust — maybe your state 2A association (but these can be bad sources, too).  The forum devoted to your state’s firearms laws can be a reasonable source, but you’ll have to slog thru all the ignorant nonsense that anyone can post to them.

Firearms are responsibilities.  The gumint makes it harder for us than it should to be legal, but the responsibility remains.

P.S. – Don’t get me started on NRA instructors.  Thank God for the NRA, and I support their realpolitik approach to making progress in the face of the fire breathers in our community.  But I tell no tales out of school when I say that their instructor programs pretty much suck and that you don’t have to be good, knowledgeable, skilled, or bright to qualify.



4 thoughts on “How to get crappy, but easy and cheap, advice on legal gun use

  1. Thanks for the kind words, Ralph. Trust you and yours enjoyed a safe and happy holiday season. 🙂

    –Andrew, @LawSelfDefense


    • Andrew,

      I have waited too long to order your book, but I corrected that today. Thanks for providing that resource.

      It looks like some of your state-specific resources are currently/no longer available. I was specifically looking at the Colorado Self-defense Law Compilation. Should I check back to your site periodically to see when that is available again, or is that something that has been discontinued?


  2. By the way, some of your readers might be interested in the recently launched “Law of Self Defense Instructor Program,” a law-school level education in self-defense law. We’ve put about 60 firearms instructors and about 20 lawyers through the program so far, and they’ve found it invaluable.

    It’s a quite intensive course, so not for the casual student or gun owner, but for the professional seeking the highest-level course on self-defense law available anywhere, it may be worth a look:

    –Andrew, @LawSelfDefense


  3. Another negative regarding LE firearms instructors:
    Most of their instruction is geared to other LEOs, who have two things lawful armed citizens don’t: A duty to pursue and apprehend, and, because of that duty, qualified immunity if things go bad.
    Not knocking LE firearms instructors; I used to be one. But LE and civilian self-defense are apples and oranges.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s